PSA Dagger: Full Size vs Compact vs Micro Explained

Palmetto State Armory sells the Dagger in three sizes, and the names don’t tell you what actually changes between them. “Full Size” sounds like a bigger gun in every direction. It isn’t. “Micro” sounds like a shrunken Compact. It isn’t that either.

I’ll sort out what each size is, what the Sabre Dagger is (a lot of people search for it), and what each size needs from a holster. This isn’t a review. We have several of those, including our PSA Dagger review, and the PSA Dagger Family Buying Guide covers the color and slide options.

The PSA Dagger comes in three sizes. The Compact has a 3.9 inch barrel and a 15 round magazine and is sized like a Glock 19. The Full Size S puts the same slide on a longer grip for 17 rounds. The Micro is a slimmer 3.41 inch barrel gun in the Glock 43X class. The Compact and Full Size S share a slide, so CYA’s Ridge holster lists both on one page. The Micro is a different gun and needs its own.


The three sizes at a glance

These numbers come from PSA’s own product listings. Heights are measured without a magazine, because PSA publishes them that way.

PSA spec

Dagger Micro

Dagger Compact

Dagger Full Size S

Barrel

3.41 in

3.9 in

3.9 in (4.5 in threaded also offered)

Overall length

6.5 in

7.15 in

7.15 in

Width

1.1 in

1.28 in

1.28 in

Height, no magazine

4.7 in

4.78 in

5.38 in

Weight, unloaded

15.9 oz

22.4 oz

22.5 oz

Capacity

15+1

15+1

17+1

The 4.5 inch threaded Full Size S runs about half an inch longer overall, because the barrel extends past the slide.

Here are the three things I’d want someone to tell me.

The Compact and the Full Size S are the same gun from the frame up. PSA describes the Full Size S as a full-size frame with a compact slide, and says it works with all of its Dagger Compact slides. Gun Digest makes the same point, comparing it to the Glock 19X and Glock 45 (a G19-sized slide on a G17-sized grip). So the only real differences are grip length (0.6 inch taller) and capacity (two more rounds, and it takes Glock 17 magazines).

The Micro is not just a small Compact. Look at the height: with no magazine, the Micro is almost as tall as the Compact. PSA built it with a full-length grip for a 15 round magazine. What shrinks is the slide (0.65 inch shorter), the width (0.18 inch slimmer) and the weight (6.5 ounces lighter). For scale, Glock lists the 43X at 6.50 inches long and 1.10 inches wide, which matches the Micro’s footprint.

The Micro’s slide doesn’t swap with the others. PSA’s own page says Micro slides fit Glock 43, 43X and 48 frames, barrels and recoil assemblies, and are not compatible with Compact and Full Size S frames. If you plan to build or upgrade, that matters.

What about the Sabre Dagger?

A lot of people search for “PSA Sabre Dagger,” so this is worth clearing up. Sabre is a trim level, not a fourth size. PSA introduced the Sabre line at SHOT Show 2024 as a premium version of the Dagger, with an aluminum flat-faced trigger, laser stippling, camo Cerakote and a titanium nitride barrel. It comes as a Sabre Dagger Full Size S and a Sabre Micro Dagger.

The Sabre Full Size S lists the same 7.15 inch length and 5.38 inch height as the standard gun, and comes with two 17 round magazines carrying +5 extensions. The Sabre Micro comes with two 15 round magazines with +2 extensions, which makes 17 rounds in the micro-sized gun.

So when you pick a size, the Sabre changes the finish and the extras, not the footprint. It does change what to check on a holster listing, and I cover that below.

Which Dagger should you buy?

Choose the Compact if you want one gun to carry every day. It has the same overall length as the Full Size S and the shorter grip is easier to hide. For a lot of people, that is the right balance.

Choose the Full Size S if you want two more rounds and a longer grip for a better hold, and you can hide the extra 0.6 inch of grip. Because it’s the same slide, you lose nothing in barrel length or sight radius over the Compact.

Choose the Micro if you need the thinnest gun, or you carry appendix in warm weather and the Compact prints. It’s a different class: lighter, shorter and 0.18 inch slimmer. For how this class compares, our post on micro-compact vs compact pistols explains the tradeoffs, and our PSA Dagger Micro guide goes deeper on that model.

If you’re weighing the Dagger against the gun it imitates, see our PSA Dagger vs. Glock 19 comparison.

Which holster fits which Dagger

This is where the sizes matter in a practical way. A holster is molded around the slide and trigger guard, not the length of the grip.

Compact and Full Size S. Because they share a slide, CYA’s Ridge holster for each lists the same models: the Dagger Compact (3.9 inch barrel, with no optic mount, RMR cut or Doctor cut), the Dagger Compact RMR (4.5 inch threaded barrel) and the Full Size S in both 3.9 and 4.5 inch threaded versions. The longer Full Size S grip just extends below the holster.

You’ll find those on the Ridge for the Compact and the Ridge for the Full Size S. The Base and Path versions exist for each size too: Compact Base, Compact Path, Full Size S Base and Full Size S Path. Check each product page’s compatibility list before you order, since I confirmed the lists on the Ridge pages specifically.

“Fits Dagger perfectly.” Al for A., on the Dagger Ridge (he carries a Compact)

Micro. It needs its own holster. The Ridge for the Dagger Micro lists the Micro (3.41 inch barrel) and the Micro with a threaded 3.9 inch barrel. It has an open front, a raised sight channel and a removable claw, and it’s adjustable for 0 or 15 degree cant.

“Fits like a glove.” Chad m., verified buyer, on the Micro Ridge

All three Ridge pages list weapon-mounted lights and lasers as not compatible, and CYA doesn’t make light-bearing holsters.

Sabre models. CYA’s listings name the Compact, Full Size S and Micro by barrel length and optic cut. They don’t mention Sabre variants by name, so if you own a Sabre Dagger, check with us before you order. The contact page is the fastest way.

If you can’t find your exact gun, the holster finder and the Palmetto State Armory collection are the best places to look.

Can I use a Glock 19 holster?

This question comes up a lot, because the Dagger Compact is built on a Glock 19 pattern and takes many Gen 3 Glock 19 parts. Our earlier PSA Dagger holster compatibility post looked into it and found that the answer is usually no for a hard-sided holster. The trigger guard on the Dagger isn’t shaped like the Glock 19’s, and the accessory rail sits lower, so the gun may not seat properly or hold its retention. A soft holster is more forgiving. We recommend a holster made for the Dagger. For why, see Best IWB Holster: Stop Buying the List, Start Buying the Fit, and for what holsters are made from, Boltaron vs Kydex. CYA’s Dagger holsters are molded on the real gun in 0.080 inch Boltaron.

Carry notes by size

PSA’s Dagger line also appears in our roundup, The 8 Best Palmetto State Armory Guns.

Frequently asked questions

What are the PSA Dagger sizes?
Compact, Full Size S and Micro. The Compact and Full Size S share a 3.9 inch slide, and the Micro has a 3.41 inch barrel.

What is the difference between the Dagger Compact and Full Size S?
The grip. The Full Size S has a longer, taller grip (5.38 vs 4.78 inches without a magazine) and takes 17 rounds. The slide and barrel are the same.

Is the Dagger Micro the same as a Glock 43X?
It’s a similar size: 6.5 inches long and 1.1 inches wide. PSA says the Micro slide fits Glock 43, 43X and 48 frames, but it isn’t compatible with Dagger Compact or Full Size S frames.

What is the PSA Sabre Dagger?
A premium trim level of the Dagger, in Full Size S and Micro versions, with an aluminum flat-faced trigger, laser stippling and a TiN barrel. It isn’t a different size.

Does a Dagger Compact holster fit the Full Size S?
On the Ridge pages, yes: CYA lists both on the same holster. Check the compatibility section of the Base and Path pages before ordering.

Does a Glock 19 holster fit a PSA Dagger?
Usually not in a hard-sided holster, because the trigger guard and accessory rail differ. We recommend a Dagger-specific holster.

Does CYA make a holster for the Dagger Micro?
Yes. See the Ridge for the Dagger Micro, and check the collection for other styles.

Do these holsters work with a weapon light?
No. CYA’s Ridge pages list lights and lasers as not compatible.

 

Justin Hunold

Firearms Writer and Firearms Expert

Justin Hunold is a firearms writer and lifelong shooter who spent more than ten years behind the gun counter at Bass Pro Shops and Dick's Sporting Goods, helping thousands of customers — first-time handgun buyers, everyday concealed carriers, hunters, competitive shooters, and law enforcement officers — find the firearm and gear that actually fit their needs.

Back to blog